Common Misconceptions about Asylum Seekers Debunked

Published: July 21, 2023

In this global age, the movement of people across borders has become increasingly fluid. These movements include asylum seekers who flee to another country due to a genuine fear of persecution or harm in their home country. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees or UNHCR defines an asylum seeker as “someone whose request for sanctuary has yet to be processed.”

This article explains the common myths about asylum seekers and provide a comprehensive understanding of their situation.

Myths About Asylum Seekers

Misconception 1: Asylum Seekers Are Undocumented Aliens

One common myth about asylum seekers is the oversimplified belief that asylum seekers are merely individuals who enter another country without proper documentation. This perception fails to recognize the complex circumstances faced by asylum seekers. In reality, asylum seekers are individuals who are forced to flee their home country to seek refuge from violence, persecution, or other forms of danger. They are driven by an urgent need for safety and protection, leaving them with no other choice but to seek asylum from another country.

Misconception 2: Asylum Seekers Are Irregular Migrants

It is important to distinguish between asylum seekers and irregular migrants. Irregular migrants are individual who cross international borders or resides in a foreign country without proper legal authorization. Unlike asylum seekers, irregular migrants do not necessarily have a well-founded fear of persecution. Their motivations for migration can be economic, social, or personal. Irregular migrants often face legal consequences and challenges due to their unauthorized status.

Misconception 3: All Asylum Seekers Are Refugees

The terms “asylum seeker” and “refugee” are not interchangeable. While they are related, they carry distinct legal definitions. An asylum seeker is an individual actively seeking protection and has yet to undergo the formal assessment of their claim for refugee status. On the other hand, a refugee is someone who has been granted international protection after satisfying the legal criteria for recognition as a refugee. Understanding these differences is crucial in comprehending the complexities of the asylum process and ensuring the appropriate application of international refugee law.

Misconception 4: All Asylum Seekers Will Be Granted Refugee Status

Contrary to widespread belief, asylum seekers are not automatically granted refugee status. The attainment of “Refugee Status” is not a straightforward or guaranteed outcome. The process involves a complex evaluation of multiple factors to assess the individual’s circumstances in accordance with international refugee laws such as the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) and the Refugee Act of 1980. While it is important to ensure that asylum seekers receive fair treatment and their claims are thoroughly assessed, the ultimate determination rests upon their eligibility to meet the specific criteria set by the law.

Misconception 5: Asylum Seekers Can Freely Work and Live in US

Upon their arrival, asylum seekers are not granted unrestricted freedom to live and work in the United States. Instead, they undergo a rigorous process that includes careful evaluation by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s (ICE) Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO). The primary objective of ERO is to monitor individuals until their status is determined or until they face deportation proceedings.

Asylum seekers must demonstrate that they pose no danger to public safety and are likely to attend all scheduled proceedings. The ICE may detain those deemed to pose a risk to public safety while allowing others, particularly women and children, to live and work under their supervision until their asylum claims are resolved. This approach ensures a case-by-case evaluation, taking into account the unique circumstances of each individual.

Misconception 6: Asylum Seekers Are Burden

Another myth about asylum seekers is that they impose an “excessive burden” on host countries. However, many fail to see that asylum seekers can actually have a positive impact on the economic and cultural development of host nations. They bring with them diverse skills, languages, and cultural perspectives that have the potential to enrich society as a whole. By embracing this diversity and harnessing the talents of asylum seekers, host countries can benefit from their integration and participation in various sectors of society.

Debunking Myths About Asylum Seekers

Understanding the status and challenges faced by asylum seekers helps foster a more inclusive and empathetic society. Asylum seekers display immense courage by seeking international protection in another country due to a well-founded fear of persecution or harm. Recognizing their rights, understanding the legal processes they undergo, and appreciating the contributions they can make to host countries are vital steps toward creating a more just and compassionate world.

As global citizens, it is our responsibility to challenge these myths about asylum seekers and recognize their need of protection as human beings with rights and dignity.

Read about Applying for US Citizenship and learn the fastest ways to Gain Permanent Residency

We Are ALG Lawyers

These myths about asylum seekers highlight the many misconceptions about human movement. At ALG Lawyers, we are committed to raising awareness and dispelling these misconceptions as we assist individuals and families in achieving their immigration goals.

With over 20 years of industry experience, ALG Lawyers has become a trusted partner for all your immigration needs.